Should Starknet become an independent post-quantum L1?

On October 8th, StarkWare announced they are actively exploring the possibility of Starknet evolving into an independent post-quantum L1, with greater control over its own security (post). StarkWare has since said which way they lean (post). This non-binding poll seeks to gauge STRK holders’ interest in exploring that direction further.

Why was this proposal made?

Security. The parts of Starknet under Starknet’s control can be quantum-resistant soon. The parts that depend on Ethereum, such as the bridge and data availability, are tied to Ethereum’s timeline. An independent L1 removes that dependency. No timeline for that exists yet, but Starknet starts further ahead than most chains. Starknet already runs on hash-based STARK proofs and native account abstraction. The core protocol is provably safe from quantum computers, and user accounts can adopt post-quantum signatures without a protocol upgrade. What remains is listed surface by surface on the Quantum Hub.

What is fixed, what is open?

Whatever the path, STRK is the token, with no new token. Bridges from Ethereum to Starknet will stay open.

What happens next?

  1. This non-binding poll seeks to gauge STRK holders’ interest in exploring that direction further. It will run for 7 days.

  2. Results will be immediately visible at poll close.

  3. If the poll result is “Yes”, a research effort on the matter will start, leading to more detailed proposals and polls.

  4. If the poll result is “No”, the post-quantum work as an L2 continues.

  5. If the poll result is “Neutral”, this thread stays open until the missing answers are in.

Vote here: Poll on Snapshot. This thread is open for comments and discussions on the matter.

yes it found smthng itrsting

Yes.

But here’s the important part:

It’s not just the hype surrounding quantum computing. We’re facing two very important issues. If you ask me, there’s only one issue, and that’s decentralization.

1- Decentralization
The current Tendermint is inadequate and must be completely overhauled; a consensus mechanism in the style of Ethereum should be developed.

2- A new token economy compatible with the consensus mechanism

Also, it bothers me that official accounts on Twitter are constantly talking about the token price.

Hi everyone,

Mon here from Cumulo. We run a Starknet validator on mainnet and Sepolia, along with public RPC and WebSocket endpoints, and we’ve voted Yes on this poll.

We think this is the right moment to explore this path. Starknet starts with a clear advantage thanks to STARK proofs and native account abstraction, and understanding what it would mean to reduce its dependency on Ethereum is a conversation worth having carefully and with real data.

If the research moves forward, we’d like to contribute from the operational side. As independent operators, we can offer a realistic view of what running infrastructure looks like day to day, and we’re happy to spin up test nodes, try early releases and share our feedback with the team.

Thanks to StarkWare and the community for opening this discussion so transparently. Looking forward to the next steps.

yes please , it will be so better

Becoming an L1 does not decentralize Starknet. It drops Ethereum’s security budget and asks the current STRK set to replace it.

Staking is still phase 2 of 4. Validators stake 20k STRK and attest with a full node. They do not produce blocks, finalize alone, or hold data availability. Sequencing and proving remain narrow roles. Reorg and censorship resistance still come from Ethereum.

The crypto agility (STARKs + account abstraction) is real and useful. The open question is whether the STRK set can carry the full security load before that floor is removed.

Questions for the team

  • Users: once finality is no longer Ethereum, who can stop, reorder, or censor a payment? Do Cairo contracts keep their address and receipts?
  • Investors: what economic security (STRK staked, cost to reorg or censor) do you target at launch versus Ethereum? Is 2027 a commitment or a contingency? Who holds bridge and liquidity risk during the switch?
  • Validators: what exact new duties (block production, finality, DA, proving) fall on them? What hardware, bandwidth, uptime, and slashing do you model? Does the 20k attester role become consensus, and at what cost?
  • Your PQ roadmap still lists bridges and data availability as dependent on Ethereum. Which dependencies disappear on day one of an L1, and which remain?
  • ECDSA.fail improved a circuit primitive. It is not a fault-tolerant attack. What observable trigger (not a date) would make the L1 move necessary rather than optional?
  • For current validators and delegators: is there a published migration spec, or is this still under study?

Until those answers are public, this is a transfer of dependency, not a gain in decentralization.

If we have a competitive advantage in this area, I believe we have a responsibility to explore it, especially given the quantum threat facing the broader blockchain ecosystem.

We should be proactive in assessing how we can leverage this advantage to mitigate long-term risks, rather than waiting until the threat becomes imminent.

A few questions I keep coming back to:

Could becoming an independent L1 turn Starknet’s post-quantum architecture into a real long-term advantage, rather than just a security feature?

How much of that advantage is limited today by dependence on Ethereum for settlement and security?

If Starknet becomes sovereign, can STRK staking and its own validator set realistically replace Ethereum’s security without sacrificing decentralization?

And could Starknet stay closely connected to both Ethereum and Bitcoin instead of becoming just another isolated L1?

I also wonder if the bigger opportunity is not “post-quantum L1” itself, but Starknet becoming a general-purpose network for verifiable computation, with quantum resistance as a natural part of the architecture.

Would that be a stronger direction?

Well noted thank you, if the poll is positive, we’ll have more public discussions about this topic

These are all valid questions. If the vote is positive, research may help answer these!

I agree with this post. This update should come with a change in the token economics, maybe the outcome of one of the last year poll, a burning mechanism.

The following reflects the views of L2BEAT’s governance team, composed of @kaereste and @Manugotsuka, and is based on their combined research, fact-checking, and discussion.

We voted NO.

We support Starknet continuing to research and prepare for a post-quantum future. Where we disagree is with the idea that becoming an independent L1 should be the direction of that work.

Starknet and Ethereum benefit from each other, and we see Starknet’s settlement on Ethereum as an important part of its current security model. Moving away from Ethereum would mean replacing those guarantees with a new consensus, validator set, and data availability model that would need to prove itself over time.

Rather than researching how Starknet could separate from Ethereum, we would prefer to see that work focus on how Starknet can become post-quantum while strengthening its integration with Ethereum and making better use of the security guarantees that come with it.

For us, preparing for a post-quantum future makes sense. We just do not think leaving Ethereum should be the goal.